Townhall.com, Where Your Opinion Counts
Talk Radio:   Bill Bennett   Mike Gallagher   Dennis Prager   Michael Medved   Hugh Hewitt   
TOP NEWS   LeftArrow - Townhall.com   RightArrow - Townhall.com  
Columns, funnies & more in your inbox!

Wednesday, April 18, 2007
Court OKs Ban on Partial-Birth Abortion
Posted by: Mary Katharine Ham at 12:06 PM

AP:

The Supreme Court upheld the nationwide ban on a controversial abortion procedure Wednesday, handing abortion opponents the long-awaited victory they expected from a more conservative bench.

The 5-4 ruling said the Partial Birth Abortion Ban Act that Congress passed and President Bush signed into law in 2003 does not violate a woman's constitutional right to an abortion.

The opponents of the act "have not demonstrated that the Act would be unconstitutional in a large fraction of relevant cases," Justice Anthony Kennedy wrote in the majority opinion.

The decision pitted the court's conservatives against its liberals,with President Bush's two appointees, Chief Justice John Roberts and Justice Samuel Alito, siding with the majority.

Justices Clarence Thomas and Antonin Scalia also were in the majority.

It was the first time the court banned a specific procedure in a case over how - not whether - to perform an abortion.

Abortion rights groups have said the procedure sometimes is the safestfor a woman. They also said that such a ruling could threaten most abortions after 12 weeks of pregnancy, although government lawyers and others who favor the ban said there are alternate, more widely usedprocedures that remain legal.

The outcome is likely to spur efforts at the state level to place more restrictions on abortions.

Alito, Roberts, Scalia, Thomas, Kennedy made up the majority.

Update: Oddly enough, there seem to be no statements on the NOW or NARAL sites yet.

The FRC blog has a pdf of the opinion.

SCOTUSblog calls the decision "sweeping" and "barely qualified" in its affirmation of the partial-birth abortion ban of 2003, and reports that Ginsburg wrote the dissent, calling it an "alarming decision."

In the course of her dissenting opinion, Ginsburg accused the majority of offering "flimsy and transparent justifications" for upholding the ban. She also denounced the Kennedy opinion for its use of "abortion doctor" to describe specialists who perform gynecological services, "unborn child" and "baby" to describe a fetus, and"preferences" based on "mere convenience" to describe the medical judgments of trained doctors. She also commented: "Ultimately, the Court admits that 'moral concerns' are at work, concerns that could yield prohibitions on any abortion."

Yes, a messaging win like "baby" as opposed to "fetus" in the opinion is certain to rankle the pro-abortion lobby.

Update: Why did Kennedy write it?

If the Chief Justice is in the majority, as Roberts was here, it falls to him to decide who’s responsible for writing the majority opinion.Kennedy probably got the call for two reasons: one, having an author of the Casey opinion put his name on today’s decision lends it a bit of extra authority, and two, since Kennedy is a fence sitter on this issue,Roberts wants to do what little he can to “lock him in” to anti-abortion precedent by making him as personally invested in it as possible.

Update: McCain and Romney are first out with pro-decision statements.

Update: Here's Rudy's statement, which is somewhat less impassioned:

"The Supreme Court reached the correct conclusion in upholding the congressional ban on partial birth abortion. I agree with it."

Update: Feminist commentary:

"We're f***ed."







FEATURES FEATURES

The Transcendental Politics of the "Natural Law Party"

Posted by: Michael Medved
7/24/2008

Defenders of Economic Freedom

Posted by: John Campbell
7/24/2008

Remembering Friend, Protector John Gibson

Posted by: Tom DeLay
7/24/2008

Your Blog Postings:
Last updated 32 Seconds Ago
Last updated 9 Minutes 9 Seconds Ago
Last updated 13 Minutes 55 Seconds Ago
Last updated 16 Minutes 4 Seconds Ago
Last updated 17 Minutes 32 Seconds Ago
 

Archives Archives

Blog Search



Townhall Blogs Townhall Blogs
Columns Columns
Your Blogs Your Blogs
By Month
 July 2008
 June 2008
 May 2008
 April 2008
 March 2008
 February 2008
 January 2008
 December 2007
 November 2007
 October 2007
 September 2007
 August 2007
 July 2007
 June 2007
 May 2007
 April 2007
 March 2007
 February 2007
By Issue
 A Culture of Life
 Budget & Government
 Campaigns & Elections
 Education
 Energy & Environment
 Faith & Family
 Foreign Affairs
 Health Care
 Immigration
 Jobs & Economy
 Judges & Courts
 Media & Culture
 Property Rights
 Safety & Security
 Science & Technology
 Second Amendment
 Social Security
 Tax Relief
Advertisement

Comments Comments

Congrats to John
 Re: Defenders of Economic Freedom
  By FOWG
From Paul Mirengauf
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By arch
Arch
 Re: OK, We Tried. The Iranians Aren't Interested In Negotiations.
  By Cicero
Patriotic Liberal babble
 Re: "Obama's No" and Letter To A Young Obama Supporter
  By CDubber
Following in the footsteps of. . .
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By Cicero
Patrioctic Liberal
 Re: "Obama's No" and Letter To A Young Obama Supporter
  By arch
THINK
 Re: Voters Uneasy About Obama ...
  By I am RIGHT
Eugene
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By arch
Pro and Cavalier
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By poyman
eddie too
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By Big G
McCain - Huckabee '08 !!!!
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By eddie
How old are you Dudley? 12?
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By poyman
Pasadena Phil writes: Thursday, July
 Re: OK, We Tried. The Iranians Aren't Interested In Negotiations.
  By arch
WW
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By Eugene
Man is that he might have joy
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By wise woman
Cicero
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By Virginia Patriot
Eugene
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By arch
Big G
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By Eugene
Arch
 Re: "Obama's No" and Letter To A Young Obama Supporter
  By Patriotic Liberal
I have a 5:30 am appointment
 Re: When John McCain Announces His Veep
  By wise woman

The Latest on Town HallThe Latest on Town Hall


Blog Roll Blog Roll