John McCain has been on the Republican equivalent of a Bed-Stuy tour.
Bedford-Stuyvesant was once a frequent campaign stop for Democratic
candidates who stood in front of destroyed or rundown buildings amid some of
the worst poverty in New York City, promising to fix the place with more
government spending.
McCain has been touring poor neighborhoods where the likelihood of his
winning votes is nil. In New Orleans, devastated by Hurricane Katrina, he
stood with the new Republican governor, Bobby Jindal, and pledged to the
residents of the 9th Ward, "the people of New Orleans, and the people of
this country that never again, never again will a disaster of this nature be
handled in the terrible and disgraceful way it was handled."
All of this is fine and it might even help diminish the usual slurs
Democrats use against Republicans about how they care nothing for the poor.
The answer to this is that if Democrats care about the poor, why haven't
they solved the problem of poverty? And the answer to that is that Democrats
need people to remain poor and, thus, dependent on them so they can get
their votes. McCain has repeatedly said he wants a "civil" campaign so don't
look for him to offer such a response.
Here is some advice for McCain: stop identifying with failure and begin
identifying with success. Before the era of entitlement and low
expectations, there were Horatio Alger stories about people who overcame
difficult circumstances and prospered. McCain should begin identifying
people who have overcome poverty and let them tell their stories of how they
did it. Those stories are better than the stories of people mired in
poverty, largely because of wrong decisions, who are doomed to remain there
because they've been told the best they can hope for is a government check.
Success becomes an example for others to follow. Stories about poverty
inspire no one.
Victory not defeat, achievement not failure ought to be McCain's strategy.
These American stories are really the story of America.
One doesn't "tackle poverty," like a football player. One shows the way of
escape and provides sufficient role models along with capital and moral and
educational structures that serve as ladders so people who want to climb out
of the hole can do so.
Here's one way it might work, based on strategies developed for the Third
World by the humanitarian organization World Vision and the micro-loan
vision of Nobel Peace Prize winner Muhammad Yunus. McCain could announce the
formation of H.O.P.E.F.U.L., which would stand for Helping Other People
Enjoy Full and Useful Lives. Churches (the moral structure), businesses
(some capital and training) and individuals (more capital and encouragement)
would be involved in H.O.P.E.F.U.L. Every American participating would
"adopt" a poor person who would be screened for drug and alcohol addiction,
criminal backgrounds and interviewed to determine whether, if given a
chance, they were - or might be - motivated to escape poverty.
Individuals would contribute, say, 20 dollars per month to a privately
managed account in the recipient's name. The money would be managed by
H.O.P.E.F.U.L. to help the poor person with a private school education, job
training, capital for starting a small business, and whatever else it takes
to help. The sponsor would be urged to meet and serve as a mentor to the
poor person, or at least correspond with encouraging words. Regular progress
reports would be sent to the sponsor(s) and when the person is declared a
success, all would rejoice and the nation would be better off. This would
not be a government program, improving its chance of success.
If you're reading this newspaper, chances are you are not poor. Do you know
any poor people? If your life has been built around pursuing happiness by
the accumulation of material goods and wealth, investing yourself in another
human being and seeing him triumph might be the greatest gift you could give
yourself and your nation. I know this from personal experience.
If John McCain rallied the good nature of Americans behind such a vision, it
could be his top achievement should he become president. And it's a good
idea, no matter who wins. |