Barack Obama chose St. Paul, Minn., to stage his victory or at least
near-victory rally Tuesday night. It was a good way to stick a thumb in John
McCain’s eye, since the Republicans have chosen to hold their national
convention at the same arena.
Yet he overlooked the historical connotations of that site. Beautiful
downtown St. Paul is where Walter Mondale delivered his concession speech
after one of the most lopsided defeats in the history of American
presidential elections: Ronald Reagan’s 49-state sweep in 1984.
For his last hurrah of the primary season, he chose a place associated with
one of his party’s great defeats. It’s as if admirers of George Armstrong
Custer were to gather at Little Bighorn, aka Custer’s Last Stand, to
proclaim victory.
It’s no a big matter. The de facto Democratic presidential nominee had good
reason to choose a battleground state and a battleground region for his big
rally. But the choice also fits into a larger, unsettling pattern: The young
senator seems tone-deaf to history.
For another example, he invoked the memory of John F. Kennedy in defense of
his sweeping offer to meet the world’s most dangerous leaders ? like Iran’s
Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and North Korea’s Kim Jong-Il ? with no conditions
attached. After all, he noted, hadn’t President Kennedy met with Soviet boss
Nikita Khrushchev early in his administration?
To quote Senator Obama: “If George Bush and John McCain have a problem with
direct diplomacy led by the president of the United States, then they can
explain why they have a problem with John F. Kennedy, because that’s what he
did with Khrushchev.”
He did it in Vienna in June of 1961, to be exact, and Nikita Sergeyevich
sized up the young president at once. His considered opinion: “too
intelligent and too weak.” It was just like First Secretary Khrushchev to
equate intelligence with weakness. One of his aides was equally blunt: “Very
inexperienced, even immature.”
In short, that meeting in Vienna - without proper preparation or any
preconditions - proved “just a disaster,” to quote JFK’s assistant secretary
of defense, Paul Nitze. The president himself agreed, telling the New York
Times’ Scotty Reston immediately afterward that his meeting with the Soviet
ruler had been the “roughest thing in my life.”
Comrade Khrushchev drew the logical conclusions from his meeting with the
new American president: The guy was a pushover. The Berlin Wall went up that
August, splitting the city and creating a focal point of tension and
violence for decades. Continued... |